GitHub - Please KEEP YOUR HANDS OFF MY USER-SPACE!

Today I launched GitHub and discovered that they decided to launch a new “feature” - the Command Palette - and that they had enabled it in my user-space without allowing me to choose first.

It’s bad enough that I have to chase Microsoft and their updates around when they break my stuff, (and I am researching dumping Windows and moving to Mint full-time), I don’t need GitHub doing that too.

Here is the posting, verbatim.

===================
begin inserted text from: GitHub - Please KEEP YOUR HANDS OFF MY USER-SPACE! - GitHub Ecosystem - GitHub Community
===================

Continuing the discussion from Notifications for new previews are annoying:

Today, I received a pop-up about a new feature - the Command Palette - that was attached to my userspace and enabled - without my consent - or at least without my explicit consent.  There’s probably some catch-all legal :poop: in the Terms Of Service that says they can do whatever they :face_with_symbols_over_mouth: well please.

At risk of sounding snarky, has GitHub been bought by Google, Facebook, (Meta), Microsoft or some other slimeware vendor?

What makes ANY company think that I want people messing with my stuff behind my back?

What makes ANY company think that this is OK in general?

Would it be OK if I went into YOUR house and changed the furniture around or re-decorated behind your back?  Or suddenly set things up with the city so that you need a “permit” (a secure certificate that costs money), just to park in your own driveway?

I just don’t understand the arrogance of this kind of thinking.

I am already having enough trouble as it is trying to develop on a Microsoft-based system where they honestly believe that they have the God-given right to sneak onto my machine and change carefully crafted preferences, settings, and applications behind my back - all under the guise of it being a “security” update?  As a consequence, things that worked yesterday stop working today and I waste literally HOURS looking for a regression in my code that turns out was a change Microsoft made while I was asleep so that their marketing guys have a reason to exist.

Yes.  I am upset.  I already have enough trouble trying to maintain a stable development platform as it is.  Please don’t make it even worse.

Suggestion:
If you want to make improvements or enhancements to improve our “experience” or make things better with our workflow, or whatever, go right ahead.  All I ask is that you tell me about the change, perhaps even explain how things will be so much better because of it, and then allow me to choose if I want it or not.

What say ye?

2 Likes

There’s an update that makes GitHub’s behavior crystal clear:

Sigh. . . .

1 Like

I don’t see it on GitHub. Apparently it’s in limited beta.
How did it mess up your code - from what I read it seems like it’s just keyboard shortcuts.
/K

1 Like

It didn’t mess up my code, (I’m perfectly capable of doing that myself!), but I have a deep-rooted objection to folks rocking the boat.

I’ve been burnt too many times. . .

1 Like